Saturday, May 21, 2011

May 21

Return to previous class

Were colonial structures set up to protect the children? No, they were property. Local governing did not want to be responsible, to protect the community & the patriarchy

Are today's prisons similar to indoor relief - workhouses

FEAR that there is a lack of resources to go around -fear of change, not understanding that we're all connected, L. scare tactics-maybe corp want ppl to only have health care from them bc they can control workers, ppl who have it good now don't want to change

Good Book -

Faces At the Bottom Of the Well: The Permanence Of Racism:

Does focus on gender seperate those oppressed? They don't work together bc fear that it will hurt their own group if they help another group.
How to affect change? Dr. B- gently move people, something in print, apps, media, pamphlets, games, history text books, Michael Moore films

Womens reproductive rights/issues: E - why can we talk about women breastfeeding at work? Women are divided about work at home vs work in workplace. Women talk about other women- having children young or old. Taking time off of work for children.

TANNF - if you r unwed mother and you don't name father on birth certificate- no benefits. if unwed teen must move back home w/ parents in order to get benefits - Bruce Jansen- we are reluctant welfare state as result of depression. Me-if everyone tithed would we notice a diff?

Unintended consequence w/ TANNF-send child back into abuse situation.

The Institution of Social Welfare
I. social Institution - set of interrelated and interlocking concepts, structures, and activities enduring over time that carry out the necessary functions of a society, such as socialization, childrearing, education, etc

II. Five major institutions of society
A. Economy
B. Polity -exercise of power
C. Family
D. Religion - ppl relate to diety and own existence - moral values about life and work
E. Social Welfare (which includes education)

III.?

IV. In reality social welfare encompasses almost every kind of service provided to members of society and provides a function to society (functionalism or here).
     A. Function is social treatment or
     B. Function is social control
-depending on side of fence, language, symbols, etc. should use appropriate style for each perspective/lens (Act 101 - teach mid class norms, CNTRL-

V. Perspectives on Social Welfare - perspective is a viewpoint based on values from which to look at a phenonmenon
     A. Functionalism of providing treatment or control
     B. Manifest functions (intended) and latent functions (unintended)- fallout i.e. requiring single mothers to name father on birth certificate - Manifest-father is also responsible for support, Latent - for some women it is recipe for disaster  (Act 101 -perhaps latent is professors think students shouldn't be here)

VI. Residual Perspective of Social Welfare( Day)-traditional perspective social welfare (as a collective unit we believe u r responsible for your own well being, therefore u should provide for your family always except in case of emergency
     A. Emergency
     B. Short-term
     C. Stopgap
     D. Means testing (closely related to 'less eligibility' from Elizabethean Poor Laws of 1601-you'll get less than the poorest wage earner of society -intention to make work more attractive) i.e FAIL
     E. Stigmatizing
     F. Grudging and minimal
Basis for the medical model of social work: 'treat & cure' people who deviate from 'healthy society'.
Leads to blaming the victim as responsible for their problems and does not consider structural problems - Do the right things and your life will get better...(if we admit there are poor-means AM not as good as we say it is)
There is a means of control involved, measurable, mangeable
-doesn't consider structural problems
VII. Institutional Perspective of social welfare - at opposite end of continuum from residual perspective. The major criterion is membership in the society.  i.e. universal health care in many nations
    A. Available to all members of society
    B. No time limit for services
    C. No means testing for determining eligibility
    D. No stigma for applying or receiving
    E. No societal pressure to leave the program

The institutional perspective leads to the structural or social model of social work: social problems lie in root problems such as classism, racism and sexism and their elimination

VIII. Conflict Perspective in Social Welfare - newe perspective based on sociological, economic, and feminist teories applied to social welfare based on conflict theory.
    A. When disadvantaged rebel against exploitation, welfare programs and benefits expand until rebellion ceases (social control)
    B. Expansion of programs and benefits are not altruisitic but rather political and economic, on individ levle ppl do it bc it makes em feel good
    C. Redefine social conflicts(control) to social problems placing the burden for change on the 'deviants'

IX. Conflict Theory says that social problems
     A. Lie in the structure of society rather than the fault of the disadvantaged
     B. Are the result of attempts of an elite group to maintain the privileges they have accumulated through exploitation of other case
     C.Will endure until the structures themselves are changed

X. Major issue from the feminist perspective is the povertization of women.  FEMINIST Perspective:
    A. Incorporates conflict theory and socialist and radical feminsit perspectives
    B. Include perspectives of the poor, women, races & religions other than the dominant white male system
    C. Sees social problems as the results class & race privilege, & patriarchal power
    D. Traces most social problems to structured inequalities
    E. Indicts social welfare as causative bc of structured inequalities


our theory comes from model of able bodied men of long ago - & way we socialize women is not to grow up and be hard workers, women are taught to be homemaker- not as simple as saying get a job, go to work that ignores the structures that put women into poverty



That's just how it's always going to be....


What is the basis for decisions? When we implement a policy, r we getting to the root of problem or just creating stopgap
OK, defined a prob, who willl do it, state fed

M. stranger/other is ppl w/o voice. Why r u involved w/ what u do?-pay it forward....relationships -developing those instead of material

Munson-social movements ppl join bc of relationships, someone they admire is doing it, 
R. ppl for most part r good, see the best in ppl,


We r - they shouldn't buy good stuff just bc they r on food stamps...-So You Think I Drive a Caddillac by Seccombe-awareness of being poor-try not to look poor in public, Poverty the 51st State-think for the moment, don't plan long term - teach Act 101 students to understand long term thinking, give them autonomy to plan schedule - if u grow up not knowing where next check is coming from
Jamie-food guy
Cultural infusion of Irish & German-drinking on sabbath...Policy is reactive- what policies make us edgy bout immigrants? Anchor baby...Trattner-what is middle class? WASP employed male and virtuous woman

L. No desire to solve problems, just way to get their votes
poverty-language used to target minorities

Spencer-social darwinist

public vs private behaviors determine how we feel about people -ok  to drink and abuse at home, not in public

metanarrative women bought into the patriarchial story

mona lisa smile use for Act 101  Ida B. Wells







Tuesday, May 17, 2011

Social Policy May 17

Trattner Abramovitz
Lecture Notes
Values article by Phyllis Day
Ida B. Wells
Policy Framework

SOCIAL POLICY AND THE STATE
Systems Perspective - look at individual and all groups/structures impacting the individual - gender, class SES, etc. not complacent w/ status quo, sociologists tend to study more vulnerable groups

Welfare - state of well being (knee jerk response is $ given to ppl-not so in this class)-  not just dpt public welfare and the benefits they provide, so it's how we use our own and societies resources to improve our state of well being. We use many benefits of society.

Chocolate cake- deboroah stone - if brought in to class & thinking of welfare of class, how would we divide the cake- typically we divide in equal pieces, we had to figure out -eligibility type criteria decisions - similar to policy makers. Their values play into the decision - article from Day...should we require drug testing, should we provide benefits to single mother who refuses to name father, how much help shud we provide & to whom? social control -Abramovitz- Personal is political ie married women couldn't have birth control, often ppl making decisions aren't part of vulnerable group, their groups voices aren't taken into consideration

Social Welfare- state of well being in which all members of society use their own resources and society's resources to achieve their goals

Zero Sum Gain - some people gain at expense of others - not enuf pie to go around

Social Welfare Policy- decisions about the prg that need to be in place

Ideology-set of beliefs about how the world works- add values- set of beliefs about how the world 'should' work. remember the droopy pants law in VA

As economy, politics, social conditions change - desire to 'help' swings back and forth from we should help to it's their own fault they are poor. We socially construct how we define and view the poor

Murray-Bell Curve- best thing that we can do as society is to repeal all laws since '65 - welfare, affirmative action, legislation for equality - our interventions have done more harm than good

Advocacy (educating) vs lobbying (influence legislation)-

Conflicting Tendencies: when creating social policy you will have the following:
A. Competing Values
B. Competing Political Ideologies
C. Conflicting Economic Interests

Two Main Ideologies:
A. Conservative
1. Government should not intervene in family affairs
2. Support status quo
3. Laissez faire

B. Liberal
1. Gov should intervene in family affairs
we have an obligation to citizens to intervene in family affairs




Think about these questions:
Ida B. Wells - A Passion for Justice
Who was seen as stranger? What was view of them
Worthy, Unworthy
Social Political Economic arena (1862-1931)
Values
Heroic figure- fought for fair play, freedom of opportunity, freedom from mob rule
campaign against oppression
after civil war-marriage allowed, wells mother 'rewed' father-mulatto,  white teachers from north served as example of Christian courage, father was active, @ 16 yellow fever killed parents- she acted like and got job as teacher- 2 yr later moved north-Memphis, [Dr. Duster-grandson]- she became editor of newspaper Evening Star, won then had case against railroad reversed- she then wrote articles/story published widely, IOLA - self help, social reform, advocate, Princess of Press, Free Speech newspaper, racism & power were subjects she often wrote about, police participated in mob violence against blacks,
The pen is mightier - Wells wrote against Memphis lynching of grocers, > Wells mobilized people> led to migration west- left Memphis went to OK,KS - businesses didn't have black customers and so went out of biz, she told blacks not to use the street cars, investigated the lynchings and wrote about the real truth. She was hired by New York Age.- Black women's club movement. She went to UK & helped launch London Anti-lynching committee - She roused public opinion in London, sent English papers to Memphis & they had to respond- mob rule became matter of public debate and lynchings ceased for 2 decades. Columbian Exposition- left out Blacks - she wrote pamphlets that showed truth - it embarrassed ppl, she moved to Chicago and continued writing esp on moral assault against Black women. southern preachers didn't fully support her - she organized Alpha suffrage movement-Black Women. Children led to what Susan Anthony called divided duty. Radicals & Accomodationists. Helped found NAACP but pushed out of power. She ran a settlement house in Chicago. Autobio-Crusade for Justice




What is social justice? Some people think it is socialism - means to redistribute wealth - negative perspective- remove wealth and give it away... way to equalize - don't have to take from wealthy - acknowledgement of 'other' group, funny how socialism is a pejorative that just stops debate - ppl think the term is used by ppl w/ an agenda to get something they don't deserve, social injustice- we look at all faults/reasons/bs what do we do to take responsibility for our situation, deviance literature- study why ppl use/abuse substances & why they don't use,


Does poverty have to exist?
Are prisons similar to indoor relief?
What does it take to resist like Ida B. Wells?
Who is your brother - what happened to the samaritan?
Does focus on gender separate those oppressed.
why haven't poverty levels moved up- what structures keep them that 'low'
how do some agitate and not get killed?
We all have story to share